Bio

Chelsey Penrice is a highly respected Muskoka real estate broker with deep roots in the region and 18 years of experience representing buyers and sellers across its most sought-after communities. Her connection to Muskoka spans generations, beginning with family history on Lake Rosseau dating back to 1945. From childhood summers to lifelong traditions spent on the water, Chelsey’s understanding of Muskoka extends far beyond real estate, it is a lifestyle she has lived and cherished for decades. This lifelong relationship with the area has shaped her authentic understanding of Muskoka’s lifestyle and traditions which has supported her success in real estate in the area she has loved for years.

Chelsey spent 15 successful years with Harvey Kalles Real Estate, where she built a distinguished career and consistently ranked among the brokerage’s top-performing sales representatives. During this time, she earned a reputation for integrity, strong negotiation, and strategic market insight, guiding clients through complex transactions with confidence and professionalism. She obtained her Broker Designation in 2013 and has since continued to lead with experience and results.

A business graduate of St. Francis Xavier University, Chelsey brings a disciplined, goal-oriented approach to her work, supported by exceptional interpersonal skills and a collaborative mindset. Her background as a varsity athlete helped shape the determination, resilience, and teamwork that clients value throughout the buying and selling process. Fun Fact she also was a proud team member for the Canadian Rugby Program in 2004.

Chelsey’s deep personal knowledge of Muskoka, from long-standing cottage traditions to the nuances of today’s market, allows her to truly understand her clients’ needs and aspirations. She believes that real estate in Muskoka is as much about lifestyle and legacy as it is about property, and she works closely with clients to ensure each decision aligns with both.

In 2026, Chelsey accepted an offer to begin an exciting new chapter with Cayman Marshall Real Estate, a move that reflects her commitment to growth, collaboration, and elevated client service. She looks forward to continuing to serve Muskoka with the same dedication and excellence that have defined her career, now supported by an innovative, independent brokerage platform.

With integrity, experience, and a genuine passion for Muskoka, Chelsey works tirelessly to help her clients achieve their real estate goals and bring their Muskoka dreams to life.